Powered bysps
        Society for Policy Studies

When the Great Game Dawned
Posted:Jan 5, 2013
increase Font size decrease Font size

C. Raja Mohan'

BooK: Return of a King: The Battle for Afghanistan

Author: William Dalrymple

Publisher: Bloomsbury

Price: Rs 799

Pages: 567

Like so much else in India’s recent past, the First Afghan War (1839-42) means little to India’s elites. But the military history of the British Raj has been a specially neglected domain. With their many other preoccupations, India’s historians have had little time for the story of war, peace and statecraft in the subcontinent before independence or after.

As America’s longest war comes to a close in Afghanistan, there is considerable interest in the West in the history of the Afghan wars. That the American occupation is ending in failure, a quarter century after the Russian troops retreated from Afghanistan, has enhanced the reputation of the country as a “graveyard of empires”.

In writing this fascinating account of the First Afghan War, William Dalrymple is inspired by the image of tenacious Afghans ousting foreign rulers and the striking similarities between America’s faltering war in Afghanistan and the first and most disastrous foray of British India into the country.

With his diligent historical research and lucid storytelling, Dalrymple paints the First Afghan War in great detail. Locating the war in the context of the Great Game between Great Britain and Russia, Dalrymple narrates the misadventures of the East India Company’s army on the Indus in Afghanistan.

After quick success at regime change in Kabul — replacing Dost Mohammed Khan with Shah Shuja — the Raj is lulled into complacence and is overwhelmed by a ferocious insurrection. A promised safe passage to the embattled Company troops turns into a massacre of the retreating columns. Calcutta responds by sending a new force of retribution that burns down parts of Kabul but is quickly convinced that withdrawal of troops and restoration of Dost Mohammed Khan is better than prolonged confrontation in Afghanistan.

Dalrymple approvingly quotes the assessment of the chaplain of the British Indian army, Reverend G.R. Kleig in 1843 that the First Afghan War was “begun for no wise purpose, carried on with a strange mixture of rashness and timidity, and brought to a close after suffering and disaster, without much glory attached to the government which directed, or the great body of troops which waged it”.

Others have told the terrible tale recently. Most notably Jules Stewart’s Crimson Snow: Britain’s First Disaster in Afghanistan provides a historical perspective that enriches the current debate on military strategy.

In the hands of Dalrymple, the drama of the war comes alive and presents a definitive message about the danger of exaggerating threats — the Russian one in the case of the Great Game and the al Qaeda more recently — and the grandiloquent agenda of nation-building in other societies.

“We in the West may have forgotten the details of this history that did so much to mould the Afghans’ hatred of foreign rule, but the Afghans have not,” Dalrymple observes.

“The West’s fourth war in the country looks certain to end with as few political gains as the first three, and like them terminate in an embarrassing withdrawal after a humiliating defeat, with Afghanistan yet again left in tribal chaos and quite possibly ruled by the same government which the war was originally fought to overthrow,” he concludes.

The real prospect of the Taliban returning to power after more than a decade of American occupation underlines Dalrymple’s insights into the First Afghan War. But there is a problem.

In Dalrymple’s story of arrogant West versus fiercely independent tribals, India is largely incidental. The first three Afghan wars were not just about the Great Game — the rivalry between Great Britain and Russia. They were also about securing India’s northwestern frontiers.

Dalrymple does concede that the First Afghan War had produced a stable frontier for the Raj for a while. But the Afghan wars were part of a much larger story about modern India: the very construction of the subcontinent’s territoriality.

The Afghan wars in the north-west, Anglo-Burmese wars in the east, Calcutta’s quest for influence in Xinjiang and Tibet, and the turning of Nepal, Bhutan and Sikkim into protectorates were all about defining secure frontiers for the Raj. They were part of a great debate in the Raj about the rewards and dangers of the “forward policy” in the 19th century, on where and how to affix India’s borders and delimit its territorial sovereignty.

Nearly 170 years after the First Afghan War, that is still a work in progress. Pakistan is struggling to stabilise its Afghan frontier. The last two Afghan wars are not simply failed interventions from Russia and America. They were and are about Pakistan’s successful manipulation of the internal politics of Afghanistan, its provision of sanctuaries to insurgents and its nurturing of extremist ideologies. Like the Raj, Rawalpindi today seeks a client state in Kabul.

The story of Afghanistan does not begin or end with Western interventions. All great Indian empires — not just the Raj, but also the Mughals and the Mauryans — had trouble controlling the territories across the Indus. These empires faced continual threats from the north-western frontiers and when the empires of the plains became too weak, they had to endure devastating invasions from rulers based in Afghanistan.

Dalrymple’s rewarding excavation of the Raj’s military history will hopefully inspire a few Indian writers to look beyond the current Western angst on Afghanistan, unravel the complex interactive dynamic between trans-Indus territories and the empires built on the Gangetic plains.

The writer is a Distinguished Fellow at the Observer Research Foundation and a Contributing Editor for The Indian Express\


increase Font size decrease Font size
Comments (Total Comments 0) Post Comments Post Comment
India's successful launch of putting a record 104 satellites into orbit is a wake-up call for China's commercial space industry which has a lot to learn from New Delhi's frugal space programme, a Chinese government mouthpiece that publishes in English said in one of its rare editorials in which it commended an Indian action
Prime Minister Narendra Modi is expected to visit Israel later this year – a first by an Indian head of the government that comes 25 years after the two countries established full diplomatic ties. The visit, a long awaited one.
spotlight image For a Dongria child, the schooling process not only displaces him of the community and the land but also displaces him from his own way of seeking truth i.e through nature, writes Rajaraman Sundaresan for South Asia Monitor.
Society for Policy Studies in association with India Habitat Centre invites you to a lecture in the Changing Asia Series by Dr.Pratap Bhanu Mehta, President and Chief Executive, Centre for Policy Research on Asia: Hope for the Future or Prisoner of the Past?    ...
spotlight image The sanctions-only approach toward North Korea spearheaded by the United States has been a conspicuous failure, encouraging the reclusive nation to rapidly advance its nuclear and missile programmes.
China bluntly warned that if the 'One China' principle is compromised or disrupted, the sound and steady growth of the bilateral relationship, as well as bilateral cooperation in major fields, would be out of question, writes Dr. Sudhanshu Tripathi for South Asia Monitor.
At the moment, Nigerian President Muhammad Buhari is able to stop the violence by pushing the Islamists to the vast Sambisa forests of the Borno State At the moment, Nigerian President Muhammad Buhari is able to stop the violence by pushing the Islamists to the vast Sambisa forests of the Borno State
Sometime in later half of last year when Indo-Pak tensions peaked, military operation heads in J&K received unusual calls on their landlines. Sometime in later half of last year when Indo-Pak tensions peaked, military operation heads in J&K received unusual calls on their landlines.

India remians the inflexible bête-noir for Pakistan, yet there are few books by Indian authors that have sought to interpret the prodigal neighbour in a holistic, informed and empathetic manner.


The line that Mortimer Durand drew across a small map in 1893 has bled the Pashtun heart ever since. More than a century later both sides of that line remain restless. But the mystery behind what actually happened on 12 November 1893 has never ...


What went wrong for the West in Afghanistan? Why couldn't a global coalition led by the world's preeminent military and economic power defeat "a bunch of farmers in plastic sandals on dirt bikes" in a conflict that outlasted b...


What will be Pakistan's fate? Acts of commission or omission by itself, in/by neighbours, and superpowers far and near have led the nuclear-armed country at a strategic Asian crossroads to emerge as a serious regional and global concern whi...


Some South African generals, allied with the British forces, sought segregation from the enlisted men, all blacks, after being taken prisoners of war. The surprised German commander told them firmly that they would have to share the same quarte...

Subscribe to our newsletter