FB   
 
Powered bysps
        Society for Policy Studies
 
 

 
the genocide that time forgot
Posted:Oct 15, 2013
 
Print
Share
  
increase Font size decrease Font size
 


Book: The Blood Telegram

Author:l Gary J.Bass

PublisherRandom House

Price: Rs 599

Pages: 499

Archer Blood was the American consul general in Dhaka (then Dacca) in 1971-72. He not only witnessed the slaughter of thousands of civilians by the Pakistani Army and dutifully reported on the genocide to his government but also, when the US continued to support Yahya Khan's Pakistan, he sent a telegram of dissent signed by most of the American consular staff and other US government officials in the city. Gary J. Bass, a professor of politics and international affairs at Princeton, a scholar who has studied the role of human rights in making foreign policy — among his earlier books are Origins of Humanitarian Intervention and Politics of War Crimes Tribunals — has made Blood's telegram and the horrific events of the 1971 war the focus of this book. Interestingly, the subtitle of the US edition is 'Nixon, Kissinger and a Forgotten Genocide' while the Indian edition is subtitled 'India's Secret War in East Pakistan'.

The logic behind this difference lies in the substance of the narrative, the reaction of two democracies, India and the US, to the slaughter in East Pakistan, which Bass equates with "the Armenian genocide, the Holocaust, Cambodia, Bosnia and Rwanda". (Just by the way, little is said of the failure of other democracies, then mainly in the West, to condemn the incident or to do anything concrete for the victims.) He is vitriolic in his criticism of the US reaction, shaped, it would appear, almost entirely by Richard Nixon and Henry Kissinger. He is only slightly less critical of the Indian response led, according to him, by Indira Gandhi and P.N. Haksar, then her principal secretary. Perhaps India comes out in a somewhat better light. Bass sees certain commonalities between the two — public opinion was outraged by the reports of the massacres in both countries as were the legislatures. But to be accurate, in the US, it was the Democrats led by Ted Kennedy who were vocal, and the press in both countries minutely followed the events and reported on the killings with horror and empathy. Bass even finds a similarity in the ruthless personalities of Nixon and Gandhi and parallels in their geopolitical responses to a humanitarian crisis. But there the similarity ends.

Indo-US relations had reached a nadir at this time and the distrust between the two countries ran deep. The degree of loathing for Gandhi, India and Indians entertained at the highest levels of Nixon's administration, expressed in coarse, almost racist if graphic language, is not as surprising as the political risks both Nixon and Kissinger were willing to take in supporting Pakistan. These included the transfer of arms to Pakistan, which were on occasion used to butcher the people of East Pakistan, the flouting of US law by arranging to clandestinely transfer airplanes to Pakistan through Iran and Jordan during the war, and, most terrifyingly, urging China to open a front against India when it seemed that the latter was about to win in the east. This was with full awareness that the USSR might get involved against China, causing a larger conflagration with the US weighing in on the side of the Chinese. These actions were not only reckless and unsupported by any direct threat to US security, but carried potentially devastating nuclear risks. Of course, this was in the middle of the Vietnam War and at the height of the Cold War — the utility of Pakistan as a facilitator of the opening to China overwhelmed any compunctions about the slaughter of Pakistani Bengalis. Yet even after direct links were established with the Chinese, the support for Yahya and his government did not waver — partly, according to Bass, because of the personal chemistry between Nixon and the General, partly not to appear weak before their newfound Chinese friends , but mainly because of his and Kissinger's visceral dislike of India.

Bass has relied on audiotapes of Nixon-Kissinger talks from the Nixon Presidential Library for his damning descriptions. On the Indian side, he has used the Haksar and T.N. Kaul papers, and papers from the Ministry of External Affairs and the Prime Minister's secretariat available at the Nehru Memorial Museum and Library and the National Archives. The Indian narrative is more straightforward and fairly well-known to concerned Indians, and almost despite himself, Bass seems to understand, if not approve, of India's actions up to the ceasefire, though he does say that India was "motivated by a mix of lofty principle and brutal realpolitik". He emphasises the huge burden of millions of refugees on a poor country and the inevitability of the "secret war" — the training and arming of the Mukti Bahini and the ultimate provocation of the Pakistani attack leading to war. His use of adjectives conveys his disapproval rather than his relation of the events: he writes of India's "flawed" democracy, her "creaky" diplomacy and her "ragtag" navy, its "rickety" aircraft carrier INS Vikrant facing the might of the USS Enterprise and of India's "isolation" in the UN and the lack of support from the non-aligned nations.

More interesting is his identification of Haksar (and D.P. Dhar) as pushing Indira Gandhi towards the Soviets — which appears to have paid off when the USS Enterprise was tailed by Soviet ships into

the Bay of Bengal. Despite the brinkmanship and posturing of the US, India won the war, and by any account, her actions and behaviour were by the book.

This is an immensely absorbing book for those interested in not just Indo-US relations but the making of foreign policy in democracies as a whole. Despite having played a minor role in the events narrated in the book and having been quoted in it, since both the role and quotes are marginal to the substance of the argument, the reviewer hopes that objectivity has been maintained in the review.

In 1971, former diplomat Arundhati Ghose liaised with the Bangladesh government in exile in India

 
 
 
 
Print
Share
  
increase Font size decrease Font size
 
Comments (Total Comments 0) Post Comments Post Comment
Review
 
 
 
 
India's successful launch of putting a record 104 satellites into orbit is a wake-up call for China's commercial space industry which has a lot to learn from New Delhi's frugal space programme, a Chinese government mouthpiece that publishes in English said in one of its rare editorials in which it commended an Indian action
 
read-more
Prime Minister Narendra Modi is expected to visit Israel later this year – a first by an Indian head of the government that comes 25 years after the two countries established full diplomatic ties. The visit, a long awaited one.
 
read-more
spotlight image For a Dongria child, the schooling process not only displaces him of the community and the land but also displaces him from his own way of seeking truth i.e through nature, writes Rajaraman Sundaresan for South Asia Monitor.
 
read-more
Society for Policy Studies in association with India Habitat Centre invites you to a lecture in the Changing Asia Series by Dr.Pratap Bhanu Mehta, President and Chief Executive, Centre for Policy Research on Asia: Hope for the Future or Prisoner of the Past?    ...
 
read-more
spotlight image The sanctions-only approach toward North Korea spearheaded by the United States has been a conspicuous failure, encouraging the reclusive nation to rapidly advance its nuclear and missile programmes.
 
read-more
China bluntly warned that if the 'One China' principle is compromised or disrupted, the sound and steady growth of the bilateral relationship, as well as bilateral cooperation in major fields, would be out of question, writes Dr. Sudhanshu Tripathi for South Asia Monitor.
 
read-more
At the moment, Nigerian President Muhammad Buhari is able to stop the violence by pushing the Islamists to the vast Sambisa forests of the Borno State At the moment, Nigerian President Muhammad Buhari is able to stop the violence by pushing the Islamists to the vast Sambisa forests of the Borno State
 
read-more
Sometime in later half of last year when Indo-Pak tensions peaked, military operation heads in J&K received unusual calls on their landlines. Sometime in later half of last year when Indo-Pak tensions peaked, military operation heads in J&K received unusual calls on their landlines.
 
read-more
Column-image

India remians the inflexible bête-noir for Pakistan, yet there are few books by Indian authors that have sought to interpret the prodigal neighbour in a holistic, informed and empathetic manner.

 
Column-image

The line that Mortimer Durand drew across a small map in 1893 has bled the Pashtun heart ever since. More than a century later both sides of that line remain restless. But the mystery behind what actually happened on 12 November 1893 has never ...

 
Column-image

What went wrong for the West in Afghanistan? Why couldn't a global coalition led by the world's preeminent military and economic power defeat "a bunch of farmers in plastic sandals on dirt bikes" in a conflict that outlasted b...

 
Column-image

What will be Pakistan's fate? Acts of commission or omission by itself, in/by neighbours, and superpowers far and near have led the nuclear-armed country at a strategic Asian crossroads to emerge as a serious regional and global concern whi...

 
Column-image

Some South African generals, allied with the British forces, sought segregation from the enlisted men, all blacks, after being taken prisoners of war. The surprised German commander told them firmly that they would have to share the same quarte...

 
Subscribe to our newsletter
Archive