Powered bysps
        Society for Policy Studies

The Warrior State: Pakistan in the Contemporary World
Posted:Jun 21, 2014
increase Font size decrease Font size
By C. Raja Mohan
Few countries get the kind of international political and policy attention that Pakistan draws. The nation’s pivotal role in shaping the global war on terror and the American occupation of Afghanistan after 9/11 has generated much work from journalists and policy wonks in recent years.
TV Paul, a reputed scholar of International Relations based at McGill University in Canada, joins the effort to understand the political paradox that Pakistan is. Unlike the fleeting reportage and instant analyses, Paul digs deep into the causes of state failure in the country.
It might be one of the world’s poorest countries, but Pakistan has played a significant role in the great power conflicts since the end of World War II. The United States and China have long valued their partnership with the Pakistan army and showered it with valuable assistance for more than half a century.
For the kingdoms of the Gulf, especially Saudi Arabia, the Pakistan army is an integral part of their national security calculus and they have always bailed Pakistan out of financial troubles.
If Pakistan’s ISI is considered one of the world’s most powerful spy agencies, its diplomats draw much international respect for their sophistication. The not-so-discreet charms of Pakistan’s thin ruling elite can bowl over even the most ardent opponents of the nation. Its writers and artists are now making a big mark on the global scene.
Despite all these advantages, Pakistan appears to have put itself on the brink of collapse. Pakistan’s economy is in a shambles and the army is desperately trying to gain control over its lawless western borderlands that are home to the world’s top terrorist organisations. Violent extremism and sectarian hatred are tearing apart Pakistan’s social fabric. Paul looks at three important ideas to explain the tragedy of Pakistan. One is the concept of “geostrategic curse”. It is akin to the “resource curse” which turned out to be the bane of many countries blessed with an abundance of valuable natural resources like oil. Pakistan, which was blessed with extraordinary geopolitical leverage after the Partition of the subcontinent, could not turn it into a tool for national development. Instead, its elites got used to the easy extraction of geopolitical rent, from the major powers as well as the Islamic world, and were unwilling to pursue the hard task of nation-building.
Second, Paul argues that after independence, Pakistan developed a world view that he calls “hyper-realpolitik” that overstated the dangers of external threats and under-emphasised the imperatives of domestic political and economic development.
Third, feeding into this was Pakistan’s paranoid quest for strategic parity with India which in turn led to the dominance of the military over the Pakistani state and prevented the emergence of sustainable domestic political institutions and a viable economic strategy.
In themselves, none of these explanations are novel. Paul’s success, however, rests in locating the study of Pakistan in the broader context of political development in the post-colonial world. Unlike many of his peers in political science departments, Paul communicates with easy prose, making The Warrior State intellectually stimulating without being pedantic.
For Paul, the story of Pakistan serves a larger purpose: to examine the various theories on the relationship between war and development. Paul contests the argument, based on European experience that war-making compels the creation of an efficient and modernising state.
Paul argues that “Pakistan’s experience shows that the war-making state may bring neither economic development nor political cohesion. If any thing can bring prosperity in the globalised world of the 21st century, it is likely to be a state that reduces the role of military and war-making efforts”.
Paul reinforces the point by comparing Pakistan’s experience with that of Brazil, Turkey and South Korea, which were once authoritarian states. He argues that all three of them have successfully transformed themselves into “developmental states”, while Pakistan has not. Paul’s use of political theory to explain the evolution of Pakistan makes The Warrior State a very distinctive contribution to the literature on the contemporary subcontinent.
The book certainly helps the Indian strategic community develop a cold and detached approach to understanding Pakistan and rise above the high emotional quotient that guides Delhi’s daily discourse on this difficult neighbour.
To develop a successful policy towards Pakistan over the longer term, however, India must combine Paul’s clinical approach with much sensitivity to the modern history of the subcontinent — especially the origins of the Partition and its bitter consequences. Even more important, India needs a measure of genuine empathy with the people of Pakistan to leaven Paul’s crystal clear judgements on state failure in Pakistan.
Book: The Warrior State: Pakistan in the Contemporary World
Author: TV Paul
Publisher: Random House India
Pages: 257
Price: Rs 499
C Raja Mohan is a distinguished fellow at the Observer Research Foundation, New Delhi, and a contributing editor at The Indian Express
increase Font size decrease Font size
Comments (Total Comments 0) Post Comments Post Comment
Nepal’s deposed king Gyanendra Shah has regretted that the country has lost its Hindu identity and said despair and unhappiness among the people might lead them to revolt once again. 


The first India-Palestine Joint Committee Meeting (JCM) signifies New Delhi’s commitment towards economic development and well being of Palestine writes Muddassir Quamar for South Asia Monitor

Intensifying searches is good. But with all this only about 15% of the tax-defaulters have been caught. Therefore the government must address the major sources of black money, writes Sudip Bhattacharyya for South Asia Monitor. 


BRICS meet in Goa

sites/default/files/Vignettes ThumbImage/1_8.jpg India-China differences and their discord over Pakistan are among differences in the BRICS that could “capsize” the grouping if the member nations fail to address competition and disagreements among them, Chinese media said today.

Well that should be it. Game, set and match. The three presidential debates — now mercifully over — have not been kind to Donald Trump, not least the constant use of the split screen which means his peevish, glowering and frequently interrupting persona is permanently on display to viewers.

In the afternoon of October 13, King Bhumibol Adulyadej of Thailand, Rama IX of the Chakri dynasty, passed away at the age of 88, in the 70th year of his reign. I ran to a café in Sukhumvit to watch the announcement, as streets in Bangkok grew quiet, people huddled around television screens, many sobbing in disbelief....


Address by M.J. Akbar, Minister of State for External Affairs on Regional Integration and Prosperity at Brussels Conference on Afghanistan (October 5, 2016). Read more inside...

The cold, hard reality of the war in Syria is that the violence, bloodshed, and chaos continues unabated while the Left, such as it is, continues on in a state of schizophrenic madness. Different points of view, conflicting ideological tendencies, and a misunderstanding of the reality of the conflict are all relevant issues to be in...

On a sunny morning a young shepherd takes his cattle across the lovely winding Namka Chu into the dense pine forests on the ridge above. The cold wind blows in from the north and the boy looks up at the steep mountain ahead of him covered by rhododendrons.


The Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan, Lashkar-e-Taiba, Jaish-e-Mohammad and others of their ilk not only destabilise Pakistan and make it one of the world's most dangerous places but also threaten neighbouring Afghanistan and India -- and even far...


The book, written in the manner of a series of case studies, also points to the lack of a clearly enunciated national security strategy, a defence situational review, a defence strategy and a joint strategy for the armed forces -- all of this h...


The book ‘Pakistan at crossroads: Domestic Dynamics and External Pressures’  is one of the few books in recent years which fixes spotlight on various aspects of Pakistan; the internal flummoxing situation and external forces wh...


In a region which is unexplored as an asset class, performance will be the kingmaker. This book includes the author’s CDCF Portfolio basket for the SAARC asset class, which selects the best fundamental-p...


Sri Lanka has to be the most beautiful country I have ever seen, says John Gimlette, an accomplished travel writer who journeys to the island nation at the end of a long and brutal civil war. Anyone who has se...

Subscribe to our newsletter