FB   
 
Powered bysps
        Society for Policy Studies
 
 

 
Calling black white
Updated:Sep 7, 2017
 
Print
Share
  
increase Font size decrease Font size
 
By Arun Kumar 
 
Demonetisation has led to much pain. Prime Minister Narendra Modi had promised that the pain would last only for 50 days, but would benefit the country enormously in the future. Invoking the image of soldiers standing at the frontier, it was said, civilians should stand in queues at the banks for a noble cause. People bought this line more or less despite the hardships, including many deaths. Nearly 10 months down the line, where does the nation stand now since the RBI has admitted that almost 99 per cent of the Rs 15.44 lakh crore of the demonetised currency returned to its coffers. In an earlier piece (‘An embarrassment of riches’ IE, August 1), I had mentioned that by January 13, 2017, 98.8 per cent of the demonetised notes were back.
 
 
The proponents of demonetisation have given a new spin. They portray the return of the notes as a success. They claim that those with black money were forced to deposit their illegal hoards in the banks and they can now be caught by the tax department and made to pay additional taxes. This, the argument goes, would expand the tax base. Further, they argue that the idle black money is now in the banks and that would lead to efficiency because the cash-to-GDP ratio would decline. They believe there is a formalisation of the informal economy and that the economy is moving towards a less cash economy. These are the long-term benefits even if there was short-term pain.
 
 
Who suffered and who gained? Are these the same set of people? A large number of those who never generated any black money were put to tremendous hardship. They lost jobs and had to stand in queues for days to withdraw their own money. Trade and businesses suffered. People were forced to return to their villages because they lost jobs in the cities. Routine banking could not be done and the aged faced enormous hardship. In contrast, the well-off never stood in queues because they had customer relations managers who helped them deposit and withdraw cash. Some of the money deposited may have been black, but it is hard to tell whether the currency was black or white since it has the same colour.
 
 
The argument that those who deposited their black money will henceforth be in the tax net is incorrect. It is unclear how many new tax payers have been discovered. The finance minister said there were 91 lakh new tax payers in 2016-17. The Central Board of Taxes has given the figure as 56 lakh and this is the figure quoted by the prime minister in his Independence Day speech. But the Economic Survey says the number increased post demonetisation by 5.4 lakh. The income declared in these tax returns is Rs 10,587 crore so the additional tax collection would be Rs 3,500 crore or 0.3 per cent of the total direct tax collection. Is this the predicted significant enhancement of the tax base?
 
 
It is also said that 18 lakh notices have been sent to those entities which deposited large sums of money in their bank accounts. Businesses have large cash in hand and that is not black. So, it would have to be established that the money deposited was from black incomes. The income tax department does not have the capacity to audit more than a few lakh entities a year. So it is not going to be able to tackle whichever is the correct figure — 91 lakh or 56 lakh or 18 lakh or 5.4 lakh entities. It will take years to collect additional taxes given that there would be litigation. The income tax department wins a tiny fraction of the cases.
 
 
Black cash is less than 1 per cent of the black wealth, so demonetisation was at best capable of unearthing just this much. But, the actual effect is far less than that because 99 per cent of that one per cent is back. So, demonetisation cannot make a dent on the black economy and its failure was a foregone conclusion.
 
 
What does it mean when it is claimed money that was outside has come into the banks or that it has got formalised? Currency in circulation is supposed to move in the economy and not sit in the banks. It also circulates in the informal economy from where it goes back and forth into the banks. Money coming to the banks is lent out to earn a return and not meant to sit idle. Unfortunately, credit off-take from banks is at a historic low because demand is short. It even turned negative for the first time in July. Once the economy picks up, the demand for cash will rise and credit would expand.
 
 
Demonetisation dented the economy severely and it has not yet recovered because capacity utilisation fell and that led to a decline in investment. The unorganised sector has declined by anything from 60 to 80 per cent, according to surveys from that period, and the rate of growth of the economy turned negative. GST has aggravated that effect because it has hit the unorganised sector hard. Thus, the economy, especially its unorganised component, has faced two shocks within six months of each other.
 
 
More digitisation, less cash economy, expansion of tax base via more raids, closing down shell companies and catching benami property could have been implemented independent of demonetisation and the huge shock to the economy. The government admits as much when it says demonetisation was only one of the steps in the fight against the black economy. If so, why pronounce that demonetisation is a success on the basis of outcomes achieved through other steps? Policy success, clearly, is being claimed by invoking afterthoughts.
 
 
 
 
 
Print
Share
  
increase Font size decrease Font size
 

Disclaimer: South Asia Monitor does not accept responsibility for the views or ideology expressed in any article, signed or unsigned, which appears on its site. What it does accept is responsibility for giving it a chance to appear and enter the public discourse.
Comments (Total Comments 0) Post Comments Post Comment
Review
 
 
 
 
spotlight image Ties between India and Japan are probably at their best ever, Japanese Ambassador to India H.E. Kenji Hiramatsu told India Review & Analysis’ Nilova Roy Chaudhury, as he outlined how the two countries have moved closer. Ahead of Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s visit
 
read-more
 India's External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj and United States Secretary of State Rex Tillerson discussed on Monday how their two countries can jointly fight terrorism and promote security in the Indo-Pacific region.
 
read-more
That regional cooperation in South Asia is lower than optimal levels is well accepted. It is usually ascribed to – the asymmetry in size between India and the rest, conflicts and historical political tensions, a trust deficit, limited transport connectivity, and onerous logistics, among many other factors.
 
read-more
Reflections on September evoke a host of memories.
 
read-more
  During the budget session of the legislative assembly, the Chief Minister informed the  House about state’s missing children. According to her, as many as 162 children have gone missing in the past three years.
 
read-more
The Communist Party of China (CPC) is expected to amend its constitution at the upcoming national congress.
 
read-more
  If anything, Aung San Suu Kyi’s 29-minute State of the Union address underlined the crown of thorns that she wears.
 
read-more
The apprehension was justified. US President Donald Trump’s disregard for institutions and fondness for reckless rhetoric meant that his maiden appearance at the annual UN General Assembly was a closely watched affair.
 
read-more
It is a privilege to be invited to this most prestigious of law schools in the country, more so for someone not formally lettered in the discipline of law. I thank the Director and the faculty for this honour.
 
read-more
Column-image

Title: A Bonsai Tree; Author: Narendra Luther; Publisher: Niyogi Books; Pages: 227 Many books have been written on India's partition but here is a firsthand account of the horror by a migrant from what is now Pakistan, who ...

 
Column-image

As talk of war and violence -- all that Mahatma Gandhi stood against -- gains prominence across the world, a Gandhian scholar has urged that the teachings of the apostle of non-violence be taken to the classroom.

 
Column-image

Interview with Hudson Institute’s Aparna Pande, whose book From Chanakya to Modi: Evolution of India’s Foreign Policy, was released on June 17.

 
Column-image

This is the continuing amazing spiritual journey of a Muslim man from Kerala who plunged into Vedic religion after a chance encounter with a Hindu mystic under a jackfruit tree in the backyard of his house when he was just nine. It is a story w...

 
Column-image

History is told by the victors but in our modern age, even contemporary events get - or are given - a slant, where some contributors soon get eclipsed from the narrative or their images tarnished.

 
Subscribe to our newsletter
Archive