FB   
 
Powered bysps
        Society for Policy Studies
 
 

 
Jadhav sentence: Indo-Pak ties in spotlight
Posted:Apr 18, 2017
 
Print
Share
  
increase Font size decrease Font size
 
Last Monday, a military court sentenced Kulbhushan Sudhir Jadhav to death over spying for Indian intelligence agency Research and Analysis Wing (RAW) under Section 59 of Pakistan Army Act (PAA)-1952 and Section 3 of Official Secret Act of 1923.
 
 
Jadhav had confessed before a magistrate that RAW deployed him for espionage and sabotage, primarily targeting Balochistan. A confessional video had been jointly released by Pakistan’s civilian and military leadership on March 29, 2016.
 
 
Jadhav had reportedly been arrested on March 3 last year from Mashkel area of Balochistan. This area is the hub of a separatist insurgency in the province. Indian officials maintain that he is a retired Navy officer with no links to security agencies. They hold that his documents were fabricated to incriminate him as a RAW spy following, what the Indian authorities claim, was a forced confession.
 
 
The matter has since remained a case of Pakistan’s claims versus India’s — true for many of the conflicts between the two states.
 
 
However, by identifying the RAW officer he reports to as Anil Kumar Gupta, a joint secretary, Jadhav has not helped Islamabad’s case, for there is no such individual in the Indian intelligence agency. And while it is usual for both countries to detain individuals from the other side over espionage charges, the announcement of a death sentence to Jadhav might hinder diplomatic progress for India and Pakistan in the foreseeable future.
 
 
As far as Pakistan is concerned, the verdict has brought important issues into the limelight. Capital punishment was certainly going to spark outrage in India, with Minister of External Affairs Sushma Swaraj already having vowed to ‘go all out’ to save Jadhav. But Pakistan’s justice system has also come under scrutiny after Jadhav’s sentence.
 
 
Both Pakistan Army Act of 2017 and the 23rd Constitutional Amendment Bill were passed on March 31 for resumption of military courts in the country. Their two-year term had expired in January this year.
 
 
Rights groups have already condemned resumption of military courts. The International Commission of Jurists (ICJ) has claimed that “the government and military authorities have failed to make public information about the time and place of their trials; the specific charges and evidence against the convicts; as well as the judgments of military courts including the essential findings, legal reasoning, and evidence on which the convictions were based.”
 
 
The lack of transparency in military courts trials was a primary concern in debates among Pakistani legislators, ahead of the passing of the 23rd constitutional amendment. These debates had continued for almost three months.
 
 
Hence, even though the verdict itself would’ve sufficed in attracting Indian indignation, the fact that the sentence was given by a military court further aggravated the outcry.
 
 
The last two Indian spies to be sentenced to death by Pakistan were given punishments by civilian courts. In 1999, Sheikh Shamim was hanged to death, 10-years after he was caught spying near the border. Sarabjit Singh, whose biopic was released last year, was killed by inmates after spending 22-years in a Pakistani jail. Meanwhile, India maintains that it has never sentenced a Pakistani spy to death.
 
 
The blowback of Jadhav’s case on Indo-Pak relations is evident, especially considering what has transpired over the past 15 months. Bilateral relations have deteriorated following Indian Prime Minister’s much-documented stopover in Lahore on December 25, 2015. We have since witnessed the Pathankot attack, Jadhav’s arrest, Burhan Wani’s death in Indian-held Kashmir and ensuing deadly violence, and the Uri attack.
 
 
Furthermore, there is the issue of the popularity of the ruling BJP’s Hindutva vision, manifesting in the hardliner Yogi Adityanath becoming the UP Chief Minister. This rise of Hindu nationalism has, intriguingly, coincided with the ruling PML-N in Pakistan manifesting liberal ideals.
 
 
While Jadhav’s death sentence may not necessarily translate into execution, what makes the verdict particularly damaging is its timing. With Pakistan set to head to polls in around 12 months, the PML-N would not want to dent its evident popularity by appearing too soft on India.
 
 
And as anti-India rhetoric would be upped in Islamabad in the lead up to the elections, we can expect New Delhi to reciprocate as India holds its elections the following year (2019) and has major state elections before that. This effectively means that any progressive development on India-Pakistan ties isn’t possible till at least 2020, despite the parallel backchannel maneuvering that the states would be engaged in.
 
 
If the entire purpose of the military courts is serve ‘immediate’ justice, the longer Jadhav remains alive the more obvious a gimmick the verdict would get reduced to.
 
 
What would happen if the death penalty is carried out? If Jadhav is hanged, it would reaffirm that the Pakistani military establishment is still calling the shots at all possible levels, despite claims that there is a progressive Army Chief at the helm now. What that, in turn, would mean is continued confrontation and diplomatic trash talk with an India that is increasingly matching its heretofore radical neighbour.
 

Daily Times, April 19, 2017

 
 
 
 
Print
Share
  
increase Font size decrease Font size
 

Disclaimer: South Asia Monitor does not accept responsibility for the views or ideology expressed in any article, signed or unsigned, which appears on its site. What it does accept is responsibility for giving it a chance to appear and enter the public discourse.
Comments (Total Comments 0) Post Comments Post Comment
Review
 
 
 
 
spotlight image Ties between India and Japan are probably at their best ever, Japanese Ambassador to India H.E. Kenji Hiramatsu told India Review & Analysis’ Nilova Roy Chaudhury, as he outlined how the two countries have moved closer. Ahead of Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s visit
 
read-more
Vowing to stop “radical Islamic terrorism,” United States President Donald Trump warned September 19 of strong action against countries that support or finance organisations like the Taliban.
 
read-more
That regional cooperation in South Asia is lower than optimal levels is well accepted. It is usually ascribed to – the asymmetry in size between India and the rest, conflicts and historical political tensions, a trust deficit, limited transport connectivity, and onerous logistics, among many other factors.
 
read-more
Former Reserve Bank of India (RBI) Governor Raghuram Rajan said ‘In order to become a more developed country, India has to get people who owe taxes to actually pay them.’ This is one of the major objectives that Modi sought to achieve though demonetization and he has largely succeeded.
 
read-more
The two-day visit to Kashmir by a Congress team headed by Dr Manmohan Singh team has called for restoration  of the dialogue with the separatists to address the ongoing turmoil in the state.
 
read-more
The Communist Party of China (CPC) is expected to amend its constitution at the upcoming national congress.
 
read-more
Médecins Sans Frontiéres (MSF) or Doctors Without Borders has urged Myanmar to grant international humanitarian organisations unrestricted and independent access to the conflict-torn Rakhine state to enable provision of humanitarian assistance to the hundreds of thousands of internally displaced people.
 
read-more
In an unprecedented warning delivered at a world forum, United States President Donald Trump on September 19 threatened North Korea with total destruction if his country is forced to defend itself and its allies against the threats from Pyongyang.
 
read-more
It is a privilege to be invited to this most prestigious of law schools in the country, more so for someone not formally lettered in the discipline of law. I thank the Director and the faculty for this honour.
 
read-more
Column-image

Title: A Bonsai Tree; Author: Narendra Luther; Publisher: Niyogi Books; Pages: 227 Many books have been written on India's partition but here is a firsthand account of the horror by a migrant from what is now Pakistan, who ...

 
Column-image

As talk of war and violence -- all that Mahatma Gandhi stood against -- gains prominence across the world, a Gandhian scholar has urged that the teachings of the apostle of non-violence be taken to the classroom.

 
Column-image

Interview with Hudson Institute’s Aparna Pande, whose book From Chanakya to Modi: Evolution of India’s Foreign Policy, was released on June 17.

 
Column-image

This is the continuing amazing spiritual journey of a Muslim man from Kerala who plunged into Vedic religion after a chance encounter with a Hindu mystic under a jackfruit tree in the backyard of his house when he was just nine. It is a story w...

 
Column-image

History is told by the victors but in our modern age, even contemporary events get - or are given - a slant, where some contributors soon get eclipsed from the narrative or their images tarnished.

 
Subscribe to our newsletter
Archive