FB   
 
Powered bysps
        Society for Policy Studies
 
 

 
Jyoti Singh and Bilkis Bano cases: Activism does impact language of judgements
Updated:May 17, 2017
 
Print
Share
  
increase Font size decrease Font size
 
We tend to wish that judges interpret the law like scientists study nature — impartially, analytically, almost anti-socially, in a secluded realm of fact measured against abstraction. The recent judgments in the rape and murder cases of Jyoti Singh and Bilkis Bano have given many causes to claim that this ideal has been betrayed. If it has, however, the fault may not lie with the judges alone.
 
The defendants in the rape and murder of Jyoti Singh have received the death sentence in a Supreme Court judgement, which refers to “savage lust” and “bestial proclivity” taking a “demonic form” in an event that amounted to a “tsunami of shock in the minds of the collective” and that “destroyed humanity”. Under the pressure of public rage, these judges opted to depict the accused with subhuman imagery, and to sentence them to the death penalty. Singh’s case was prosecuted in four and a half years.
 
As for Bilkis Bano, a victim of gang rape during the Gujarat riots, it took 15 years for only a state-level judgment. The judges of Bombay High Court rejected the charge of conspiracy, describing the attack as “spur of the moment” despite also saying the attackers were “hunting for Muslims”, and sentenced the perpetrators not to the death penalty — as the CBI recommended — but rather to life in prison. Bano had received little of the intense public attention devoted to Jyoti Singh.
 
In Engines of Liberty: The Power of Citizen Activists to Make Constitutional Law, American legal scholar David Cole argues that some of the most important recent Supreme Court decisions in the US have, for better or for worse, been the product of sustained campaigns of public activism and advocacy.
 
In 1972, before most Americans were likely familiar with the concept of gay marriage, the Supreme Court replied to an appeal regarding it with a curt, sentence-long dismissal. Fourteen years later, it ruled that states could make gay sex a crime. Meanwhile, the AIDS crisis was encouraging an unprecedented degree of organisation and agitation in the American gay community. The social movement that was born found a legal counterpart in organisations like Freedom to Marry, which raised millions of dollars to fight cases related to gay marriage. By 2015, in a society with tremendously changed attitudes, gay Americans had gained a new constitutional right.
 
Few would say that the influence of civilian activism on constitutional law is entirely benign. Many supporters of gay marriage deplore America’s skimpy regulation of guns, for example, but Cole shows that civil society groups were equally responsible for causing the Supreme Court to dramatically reinterpret gun rights.
 
In 1990, a former Republican member of the Court was reflecting conventional wisdom when he dismissed the idea that there was an “individual right to bear arms” as “one of the greatest pieces of fraud… on the American public by special interest groups that I have ever seen in my lifetime.”
 
In 2008, however, after a long and expensive legal campaign run largely by the National Rifle Association — an organisation that commands an annual budget of about a quarter of a billion dollars and boasts three-to-five million members — the Supreme Court ruled the right to bear arms to be constitutional.
 
The new rights won by gay people and gun owners in the US came at the same time that each group newly asserted itself and won political power.
 
The text of the law at any given time is fixed, but its meaning and application remain a social fact.
 
Hindustan Times, May 18, 2017
 
 
 
 
Print
Share
  
increase Font size decrease Font size
 

Disclaimer: South Asia Monitor does not accept responsibility for the views or ideology expressed in any article, signed or unsigned, which appears on its site. What it does accept is responsibility for giving it a chance to appear and enter the public discourse.
Comments (Total Comments 0) Post Comments Post Comment
Review
 
 
 
 
spotlight image Vitaly A. Prima, Ambassador of Belarus to India for close to five years, is very enthusiastic about the future of bilateral relations as the two countries mark 25 years of diplomatic relations. Resident in New Delhi, Prima is also his country’s Ambassador to Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and Nepal.
 
read-more
India’s top diplomats held a four-day brainstorming session in New Delhi this month to strategise and decide how India should engage with major global powers and countries in the immediate neighbourhood, writes Nilova Roy Chaudhury
 
read-more
Video Gallery

 
see-more
Is it the Modi magic or Modi cult propelling the BJP to new heights with the opposition pulverised and decimated by the split vote banks of these parties in large parts of India? The BJP has gained five states in the assembly elections but lost Delhi and Bihar, writes Lalit Sethi
 
read-more
Several prominent citizens from different walks of life have called for a declaration of ceasefire in Kashmir during the month of Ramzan, beginning on Friday. Their appeal needs to be immediately heeded, both by the Centre and the state government.
 
read-more
Recently, quite a few stories have appeared on the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) in both local and international publications.
 
read-more
What a week it has been for the Middle East! People of Iran came out in droves to re-elect Rouhani as president for another term.
 
read-more
Poor Donald Trump. Back from his whirlwind Middle East tour — to escape rumours about how deep his closeness to a certain world leader runs — only to find talk of his loose lips still looming large, rather like a third presence, over the NATO summit.
 
read-more
Column-image

Jim Corbett was a British-Indian hunter and tracker-turned-conservationist, author and naturalist; who started off as an officer in the British army and attained the rank of a colonel. Frequently called in to kill man-eating tigers or leopards,...

 
Column-image

Title: Bollywood Boom; Author: Roopa Swaminathan; Publisher: Penguin; Price: Rs 399; Pages: 221

 
Column-image

Title: Defeat is an Orphan: How Pakistan Lost the Great South Asian War; Author: Myra Macdonald; Publisher: Penguin Random House India; Pages: 328; Price: Rs 599

 
Column-image

  The story of Afghanistan -- of the war against the Soviets and of terrorism that has gripped the landlocked country ever since -- is in many ways also the story of diplomat Masood Khalili, who motivated his people and led them...

 
Column-image

Title: The Golden Legend; Author: Nadeem Aslam; Publisher: Penguin Random House; Pages: 376; Price: Rs 599

 
Subscribe to our newsletter
Archive