ICJ’s Myanmar Ruling a Landmark Moment in International Law
Wider interest in the Myanmar case is reflected in the participation of eleven countries in the case: Belgium, Canada, Denmark, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, France, Germany, Ireland, the Maldives, the Netherlands, Slovenia and the United Kingdom. Yet, they are not parties to the dispute.
The International Court of Justice's (ICJ) ruling of 19 November, finding Myanmar responsible for genocide against the Rohingya, is a landmark moment in international law. Its significance goes well beyond Myanmar and establishes an important precedent for determining when a state can be held legally responsible for genocide, how genocidal intent is established, and what obligations governments have to prevent and punish mass atrocities.
Perhaps its most important consequence is that it gives other countries and legal teams a concrete judicial precedent to consider in ongoing genocide cases, particularly South Africa's case against Israel concerning Gaza. South Africa alleges that Israel has violated the Genocide Convention through its military operations in Gaza. Israel rejects the genocide allegations.
The European Union in a statement noted that “the Rohingya people have endured immense suffering, including displacement and violence, and their plight must not be forgotten. This landmark ruling underscores the imperative of justice for victims and the necessity of upholding international law.”
The 27-member bloc called on Myanmar to fully implement the ICJ’s ruling without delay, including its obligation to provide restitution and compensation for the damage caused as far as such damage is not made good by restitution.
Compliance with ICJ’s decisions is not optional; it is an obligation under international law, stressed the EU statement.
A Binding Judgement
Wider interest in the Myanmar case is reflected in the participation of eleven countries in the case: Belgium, Canada, Denmark, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, France, Germany, Ireland, the Maldives, the Netherlands, Slovenia and the United Kingdom. Yet, they are not parties to the dispute. They have intervened because they consider that the interpretation of the Genocide Convention is at stake. Under Article 63, the court’s interpretation of the Convention will also be binding on the states that have intervened.
The International Court of Justice (ICJ), also known as the World Court, is the principal judicial organ of the United Nations. It was established in 1945 and began work in 1946, succeeding the Permanent Court of International Justice. It is based in the Dutch city of the Hague.
The western media have underlined the importance of the decision. “The impact of the ICJ’s genocide ruling in Myanmar will go far beyond Asia,” commented a Brussels-based publication Euobserver
It noted that one of the most important precedents is the court’s 2007 judgment in Bosnia and Herzegovina v Serbia and Montenegro. Bosnia brought its case in 1993, alleging that Serbia was responsible for genocide committed during the Yugoslav war. In 2007, the court found that genocide had been committed in Srebrenica in July 1995.
But it did not find that the acts of genocide could be attributed to Serbia. It held that Serbia had nevertheless breached its obligations to prevent genocide and to punish those responsible
German daily Der Tagesspiegel commented that “the ruling will have far-reaching consequences for other trials of this kind. In particular for the ongoing proceedings against Israel. ... And that could already be causing unease. Because the court's reasoning has shown that it is indeed possible to prove intent without a written plan for extermination”.
In the case brought by The Gambia against Myanmar, the ICJ found, by a 9–6 majority, that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya population during the military's 2017 clearance operations in Rakhine State.
The court found that Myanmar had violated several obligations under the 1948 Genocide Convention, and that the state was held internationally responsible for genocide against the Rohingya and failure to prevent genocide.
It ordered Myanmar to investigate and prosecute suspected perpetrators, prevent further violations, provide guarantees of non-repetition, facilitate safe and voluntary returns and family reunification, and compensate the Rohingya.
First Time a State Indicted
Importantly, this is the first time the ICJ has found a State responsible for committing genocide itself. This is perhaps the ruling's greatest contribution.
International criminal tribunals generally prosecute individuals: military commanders, political leaders and those who directly participate in atrocities. The ICJ, by contrast, determines disputes between states. It has now made an explicit finding that a State committed genocide and breached its treaty obligations.
This reinforces an important principle: governments cannot escape international responsibility simply because atrocities were carried out by military institutions or individual soldiers.
Moreover, a government cannot automatically escape a genocide allegation by arguing that its military was conducting a counterterrorism operation, fighting insurgents or pursuing legitimate security objectives.
The court examined the overall pattern of conduct, including killings, sexual violence, attacks on children, destruction of villages and other evidence, to establish genocidal intent.
Importance of Prevention
The broader legal significance is that the existence of military objectives does not necessarily exclude an intention to destroy a protected population, in whole or in part.
This is particularly relevant to cases where governments argue that civilian casualties occurred during legitimate military operations.
The Genocide Convention does not simply prohibit governments from committing genocide. It also requires states to take reasonable measures to prevent genocide when they know, or should normally have known, of a serious risk that it may occur.
The Myanmar judgment reinforces the importance of prevention, investigation and punishment. This matters because international justice should not begin only after thousands of people have been killed or displaced.
(The author is Brussels-based Non Resident Fellow of the New Delhi-based Society for Policy Studies who has been tracking and reporting on EU and European affairs and NATO for the past four decades. The views expressed are personal. He can be reached at nawab_khan@hotmail.com. X: @NawabKhan10)

Post a Comment