Whose City is it? Reclaiming the City Through the 'Right to Walk'

Development of a city cannot be measured only through kilometres of asphalt laid or investments it attracts. It must be measured through the extent to which a person can walk safely from one neighbourhood to another avoiding the cars, physical barriers and complicated bureaucracy.

Saka Keerthana Nov 18, 2026
Image
Representational Photo

A city can indeed have great sidewalks, signs, and crosswalks, or even plans for how people move around, and at the same time, be inaccessible to the people that depend on these services. This leads to a dilemma for both the citizens and the planners, if the infrastructure exists and the objectives remain unmet, what are we trying to fix?

During my internship in Hyderabad in June, the traffic jam that stretched for nearly two hundred metres in front of me caused the contradiction to be stark. Even though the traffic was hardly moving, the cars and motorbikes were completely occupying the street space meant for walking.

The irony was striking. At that moment, the footpath was possibly the best form of transportation in Hyderabad. While cars were stuck in traffic jams, pedestrians could move freely. But even that was not straightforward. Instead of having an unobstructed space people had to manoeuvre through the vehicles parked along the footpath.

It was not simply a question of traffic congestion; it was a profound question of priority.

Illusion of Car-Centric Development

In urban development discussions in India, the emphasis is mostly on constructing such things as: wider roads, skyways, metros, bridges. Although such developments matter, that does not necessarily make them accessible. A sidewalk can be built without providing access to it. A pedestrian crossing can be created, but without securing a safe passage for pedestrians.

Urban spaces are not neutral. They reflect calculated decisions as to who is prioritised and whose needs are acknowledged. When a project enhances the travel options of a car driver, it often comes at the expense of a pedestrian not being able to cross the road safely. Certain activities are invariably displaced in the process of developing a "beautified" public space.

The very concept of car-centric urban planning and treating pedestrians as an ancillary mode of transport has been challenged by the ruling of the Supreme Court of India. On 19 June 2026 in Maniyar Iliyaz @ Shaik Riyaz & Anr. v. P. Ayyappan & Ors., the Court formally recognized that the right to walk is a fundamental right under Part III of the Constitution of India.

The Court held that the right to walk was integrated to the right of free movement guaranteed under Article 19(1)(d) and to the right to life under Article 21. Of great significance, the Court held that the right to pedestrian paths, which are safe and demarcated, takes precedence over the passage of motorized vehicles, thus changing the debate from that of civic charity to constitutional guarantee.

Translating Right to Practice

The recognition of a right is just the start of the process. The harder question becomes how to translate the right into practice. Whenever there is the existence of infrastructure but the civic compact fails, the problem arises because of three major shortcomings:

The Flaw in Design: Traditional engineering paradigms see footpaths as residual concrete rather than as a coherent passage available to all. Designs often ignore the actual movements of human beings, leading to creation of dead ends and stumbling blocks.

The Crisis of Governance: One of the most enduring problems in Indian cities is the gap between what the policies intend and what occurs at ground level. Responsibilities are distributed among many institutions. Who is responsible when the footpath is blocked with parked cars? Is it the traffic police, municipal corporation, or road owning body? In the case where the responsibility is dispersed across many agencies, enforcement becomes passing of the buck.

Mirror of Social Behaviour: Think of a scenario where a traffic light turns red. One car jumps the red light; another one follows, and after sometime, the whole idea of a traffic intersection gets obstructed with vehicles all over the place. 

When traffic rules are never enforced and the footpath gets taken over, the behaviour becomes part of the social order. But such behaviour is moulded by the institutions. When the authorities do not provide pedestrians with their space, they exclude pedestrians from public infrastructure.

Whither Right of Pedestrians?

A Supreme Court judgment laid down parallel responsibilities of urban planning bodies, municipalities, and panchayats regarding demarcation, upkeep, and safeguarding of pedestrian infrastructure. Legal recourse in terms of restitution and compensation has been provided by the court in case of violation of this right.

Such an approach empowers citizens but at the same time takes the discussion back to the primary political debate about urban planning: 'Shehar banega kiske hisaab se'? (According to whose vision will the city be built?)

When the city's governance is dictated by the interests of private car users and disparate city institutions, it is unlikely for the pedestrians to have their fundamental dignity acknowledged. So perhaps Sheher Kiska? (who does the city belong to) is not a question of property ownership, but a question of belonging, representation, and power. 

The right to walk implies the responsibility of institutions to be accountable for their actions, to adopt an inclusive approach to city planning, and to fundamentally change the approach to the idea of public spaces in our cities.

Reclaiming the City Pavement

The most significant takeaway from that June evening stroll in Hyderabad was not that the city needed to construct a new footpath. The reason was that the current footpath had to serve as a single unit.

As urban planners, researchers and citizens we devote a lot of time to talking about what should be built. However, it is equally important to pay attention to how one experiences, manages and uses existing transportation. Development of a city cannot be measured only through kilometres of asphalt laid or investments it attracts. It must be measured through the extent to which a person can walk safely from one neighbourhood to another avoiding the cars, physical barriers and complicated bureaucracy.

If a city belongs to everyone, its public spaces should serve all people. The real indicator of urban development is not the speed of vehicle movement, but the degree of comfort provided to the people moving.

(The author is pursuing my Master's in Urban Studies at Dr. B.R. Ambedkar University Delhi who is drawn to questions surrounding urban governance, public policy, mobility, infrastructure and the social dimensions of urban development. The views expressed are personal. She can be contacted at keerthanasaka@gmail.com )

Post a Comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Newsletter Subscription

The subscriber's email address.
Stay informed - subscribe to our newsletter.